Bus bombing raises pressure on EU to outlaw Hezbollah
February 5, 2013
A finding that Hezbollah is to blame for the bomb attack that killed five Israeli tourists in Bulgaria last July adds to pressure on the European Union to label the controversial group an outlaw terrorist organization.
The Bulgarian government’s announcement of its conclusions Tuesday also could complicate life for Lebanon’s coalition government, of which Hezbollah is a member.
Bulgarian Interior Minister Tsvetan Tsvetanov told reporters in Sofia that of the three people who carried out the attack, “We have established that two were members of the militant wing of Hezbollah. There is information that shows financing and the connection between Hezbollah and the two suspects.”
He also said the pair had traveled on genuine Australian and Canadian passports, though it’s not clear whether the documents had been stolen.
Hezbollah has said nothing about Israel’s previous accusation that it was responsible for the attack, which occurred outside a bus waiting at the airport in the Bulgarian resort of Burgas.
The United States and Israel seized on the conclusion of the Bulgarian investigation to urge the EU to move against Hezbollah. President Barack Obama’s counterterrorism adviser, John Brennan, said Tuesday the investigation had exposed Hezbollah as “a terrorist group that is willing to recklessly attack innocent men, women, and children, and that poses a real and growing threat not only to Europe, but to the rest of the world.”
In a statement issued from the White House, Brennan said, “Bulgaria’s implication of (Hezbollah) underscores the importance of international cooperation in disrupting terrorist threats.
“We call on our European partners as well as other members of the international community to take proactive action to uncover (Hezbollah’s) infrastructure and disrupt the group’s financing schemes and operational networks.”
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also commended the Bulgarian investigation, saying: “The attack in Burgas was an attack on European soil against a member country of the EU. We hope that the Europeans draw the necessary conclusions as to the true character of Hezbollah.”
Canada also joined the chorus, with Foreign Minister John Baird issuing a statement saying: “We urge the European Union and all partners who have not already done so to list Hezbollah as a terrorist entity and prosecute terrorist acts committed by this inhumane organization to the fullest possible extent.”
A technical analysis of the explosion, carried out by a team of consultants and provided on background to CNN, said the Israeli tourists had placed their luggage in a baggage compartment along the side of the bus and were boarding when the explosion occurred. The bomb — concealed in a backpack — went off in a confined space between two buses, instantly killing four of the tourists and the bus driver, as well as the bomber.
The consultants’ analysis of closed-circuit video of the suspected bomber waiting in the terminal and of the remains of the device suggests that the bomb was detonated by remote radio control. Residue from two radio transceivers was recovered from the scene, along with a dual-tone multiple-frequency circuit. The explosive charge was approximately 3 kilograms (6 pounds) of TNT and ammonite, probably obtained from a Bulgarian company, according to the consultants.
Whether the bomber intended to kill himself is unclear. It is possible that he planned to load the backpack on the bus and detonate it remotely as it pulled away. The premature detonation of the device before all members of the Israeli group were on board the bus could have been caused by a malfunction or by violent movement, or it could have happened as the device was being armed.
Alternatively, an accomplice could have detonated the bomb from a nearby vantage point, in which case the bomber may have been deceived about his true role in the attack.
Bulgarian investigators last month said their evidence was that the bombing was not intended as a suicide attack.
Analysts say the attack was not that of a “lone wolf” but rather required planning and reconnaissance, suggesting a well-orchestrated plan.
Last year, Matthew Olsen, director of the U.S. National Counterterrorism Center, said in a congressional hearing that the Bulgarian attack could have been part of a growing international campaign of terror attacks by Hezbollah.
“Since May 2008, Hezbollah plots against Israeli targets in Azerbaijan, Egypt and Israel have been disrupted, and additional operational activity in Turkey has reportedly been uncovered,” Olsen said.
But while the United States has stepped up efforts to interdict Hezbollah’s international financial operations, the group has enjoyed greater freedom in Europe.
Germany’s annual threat report in 2012 concluded that nearly 1,000 Hezbollah members and supporters lived there. Hezbollah raises money quietly in several European cities, according to intelligence agencies, to support its extensive network of social programs in Lebanon.
Only the Netherlands among the main European governments describes Hezbollah as a terrorist organization. Britain distinguishes between its military wing — which is proscribed — and its work as a political party in Lebanon. France and other EU states do not characterize any part of Hezbollah as a terrorist organization.
If the European Union moves toward unified sanctions against Hezbollah, the current Lebanese coalition government led by Prime Minister Najib Mikati may be in jeopardy
Mohanad Hage Ali, a Lebanese expert on Hezbollah based at the London School of Economics, told CNN, “Since Mikati formed his government two years ago, there has been steady European support. But since Hezbollah is part of this government, more EU member states are likely to dissociate themselves from Mikati’s government” if the link with the Bulgaria bombing is confirmed.
“Since the 1980s,” he added, “the United States listing of Hezbollah on its list of terrorist organizations has been seen as a unilateral act, while the Lebanese party was improving its international relations, especially with EU states. This may now change.”
Mikati said Tuesday his government is “ready to cooperate in clarifying the circumstances” of the attack “in fairness and safeguarding justice,” but he did not address the accusations against Hezbollah .
Hage Ali said that if Hezbollah were designated a terrorist group by the EU it would virtually eliminate the European role in mediating between Hezbollah and Israel on such issues as negotiating prisoner exchanges.
Germany has been especially active in mediating on humanitarian issues. But there have been signals in the past few months from senior figures in Angela Merkel’s coalition that the mood is shifting.
Last August, the foreign policy spokesman for Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union, Philipp Missfelder, told the Jerusalem Post it was “long overdue to place Hezbollah on the EU’s list of terror organizations.”
The British foreign secretary, William Hague, has also called on the EU to reopen discussions on Hezbollah’s status.
Lebanon says ready to work with Bulgaria in bomb probe February 05, 2013 06:14 February 05, 2013
BEIRUT: Prime Minister Najib Mikati said Tuesday Lebanon would cooperate with Bulgaria to unravel the circumstances of the 2012 bus bombing in Burgas after a probe implicated Hezbollah in the attack, as the United States and Israel stepped up pressure on the EU to take action against the Lebanese group.
The head of the European Union, Chatherine Ashton, said European states needed to reflect carefully on the results of the probe.
"Lebanon affirms its confidence that the concerned authorities in Bulgaria will seriously evaluate the results of these probes and [Lebanon] affirms its readiness to cooperate with the Bulgarian state to unravel the circumstances of this issue to achieve fairness and safeguard justice,” Mikati said, according to his office.
Mikati, who traveled to Bulgaria on an official visit last year, said his country condemns and opposes “any act or attack targeting any Arab or foreign country.”
Earlier Tuesday, Bulgaria’s interior minister said a probe into the July 18, 2012, bus bombing in the Black Sea resort of Burgas pointed to Hezbollah’s involvement, an allegation that both Israel and the U.S. maintain.
Bulgarian Minister Tsvetan Tsvetanov said three people were involved in the attack, two of whom had genuine passports from Australia and Canada.
"There is data showing the financing and connection between Hezbollah and the two suspects," Tsvetanov told reporters.
"What can be established as a well-grounded assumption is that the two persons whose real identity has been determined belonged to the military wing of Hezbollah," he said.
Both Israel and the U.S., which both regard Hezbollah as a terrorist organization, urged the EU to take action against the resistance group.
Ashton, according to a statement from her office, said European states needed to reflect carefully on the results of a probe.
“The implications of the investigation need to be assessed seriously as they relate to a terrorist attack on EU soil, which resulted in the killing and injury of innocent civilians,” the statement said.
She also stressed the “need for a reflection over the outcome of the investigation,” adding that the EU member states would discuss “the appropriate response “based on all elements identified by the investigators."
Mikati said Lebanon was keen on maintaining it sties with Bulgaria and other EU states.
“Lebanon emphasizes its tight relationships with Bulgaria and the European Union and its keenness on Bulgaria's security as well as that of the whole union and its desire is to keep good relations and develop it at all levels on the basis of mutual respect and in accordance with the rules governing countries' relations,” Mikati said.